SemiBase

Variety V[6, 8564] no finite basis

The variety generated by [6, 8564], the Brandt monoid B₂¹, obtained from B₂ by adjoining an identity: all semigroups that satisfy every identity of B₂¹. It has no finite basis. It is self-dual, since B₂¹ is anti-isomorphic to itself, and no other semigroup of order at most six generates it: the variety of a finitely based semigroup has a finite basis, and the identities below tell it apart from the varieties of L, A₂ᵍ and A₂¹.

No finite basis

For every n, the identity

x y₁⋯yₙ x yₙ⋯y₁ ≈ x yₙ⋯y₁ x y₁⋯yₙ

holds in B₂¹. A pattern in the occurrences of the letters survives every derivation step with an identity in fewer variables; the argument uses that xytyx and xtyxy are isoterms, equal in B₂¹ only to themselves. A finite set of identities uses boundedly many variables, so it misses one of these identities and is not a basis.

Argument: P. Perkins (1969), in the reconstruction of M. V. Sapir (1988). The Lean theorem is on the page of [6, 8564]; see also the four semigroups without a finite basis.

The four varieties without a finite basis

V[6, 3843], V[6, 8564], V[6, 8878] and V[6, 13747] are distinct: each pair differs on one of these identities.

IdentityLB₂¹A₂ᵍA₂¹
x² ≈ x³holdsholdsfailsholds
xyx ≈ x²yxholdsfailsfailsfails
x²y² ≈ xy²xfailsholdsfailsfails

Among the 681 finitely based varieties

B₂¹ lies in none of them, so neither does this variety. Which of them lie in it is not decided here: without a finite basis there is no basis to evaluate.

The name is permanent: [6, 8564] is the only generator of order at most six. See how the varieties are named.